Editorial Team
How We Research and Review Tours
Last updated November 9, 2026
American Trip Insider is part of the Going South Travel network, and its guides are written by the American Trip Insider Team. This page explains exactly how our tour comparisons are put together, so you can judge how much weight to give them.
What our recommendations are based on
Our tour guides are comparisons, not first-person trip reports. For each page we:
- Check every listing on the day we publish: live prices by date, option and age, start times, group sizes, meeting points, what is and is not included, and cancellation terms, taken directly from each tour's booking listing.
- Read guest reviews in bulk: usually 400 to 800 recent reviews per guide, always including the low-rated ones, so we can see what goes wrong as well as what goes right. We report how many we read on every page.
- Check official sources: park services, museums, ferry operators and city agencies for opening hours, ticket prices and rules, with links to the source on the page.
- Leave tours out on purpose: any tour without recent reviews, near-duplicate listings, and tours whose recent reviews describe repeated problems.
What we have and have not done in person
We have not personally taken every tour we compare. When a page says guests found a cruise crowded or a guide hard to hear, that comes from patterns across many reviews, not from our own visit, and we say so in the text. When we add our own photos or first-hand notes to a guide, we will label them clearly.
How we choose our top pick
Our pick is the tour we would book first for most visitors, weighing recent review quality (not just the star average), what is included for the price, group size, and how often recent guests report the same problem. Tours with only a few recent reviews are never our top pick.
How we make money
When you book a tour through the availability widget on our pages, we may earn a commission from the booking platform, at no extra cost to you. Commission rates do not affect which tours we include or rank, and we regularly recommend free or cheaper official alternatives, such as buying a ferry ticket directly, when they are the better choice.
Corrections and updates
Every guide shows the date we last checked it. Prices and schedules change, so always confirm details with the operator before you book. When we recheck a page, we update the prices, dates and review counts together.